The Key Question in a Job Interview

Job Interview Hir­ing the right per­son for a given job can be a bit of a craps shoot for many busi­ness own­ers — and for some HR man­agers as well. It seems obvi­ous that the most impor­tant things you want to answer are whether they can do the job and whether they fit into your team. But those are not paramount.

Guess­ing again? Integrity, intel­li­gence, suit­abil­ity to your “fast-paced envi­ron­ment”, exper­tise, ambi­tion, work ethic… all are plau­si­ble guesses about what the most impor­tant fac­tor might be in a poten­tial hire. And cer­tainly, most of these are impor­tant fac­tors, but none of them are crit­i­cal for the inter­view. I’m assum­ing, of course, that you aren’t going to make peo­ple fill out some inane apti­tude test or issue some irrel­e­vant quiz about what kind of tree they’d most like to be.

The Benefit of Failure

J.K. Rowling at Harvard Commencement Via TED’s Best of the Web Talks, I dis­cov­ered J.K. Rowl­ing’s Har­vard Com­mence­ment Address in June 2008 on The Fringe Ben­e­fits of Fail­ure, and the Impor­tance of Imag­i­na­tion. The sub­ject brings up an impor­tant con­cept — the fact that although we list only suc­cesses on our CVs, it is typ­i­cally the fail­ures that teach us more. Com­par­a­tively, suc­cess per­haps teaches us very lit­tle. When was the last time you judged some­one as qual­i­fied because of the lessons learned in their last fail­ure? Granted, this might not be the sin­gle best cri­te­ria, but some­one who’s never failed may well be an under­achiever stuck within the con­straints of mediocre thinking.

J.K. Rowl­ing:

Job Interview Presentation: Sprucing Up or Deception?

Overheard in a supermarket checkout line this past weekend, one woman to another:

"Oh my God, [Leanne] bought a pair of fake glasses and wore them to an interview because she felt more intelligent. I mean, it's not like they're going to say, 'Hire the one with glasses because she's more intelligent.'"

It just got me to thinking, and wondering if Leanne is (a) being dishonest with her prospective employer, albeit in a seemingly benign way, or (b) creative, original, and smart. I'm sure the interviewer would be able to size up pretty quickly whether she's an airhead or the real deal, but my jury is still out on whether or not the action is duplicitous.

The Case Against Vacation Policy

There’s a case being made against vaca­tion pol­icy that fixes a set num­ber of vaca­tion days per year. The argu­ment runs that staff should have as much vaca­tion as they want, when­ever they want… pro­vided they meet their goals. The cynic in me says that some staff are going to try to claim over­time to meet their goals so they can have more paid vacation.